Two years ago, screenwriter Diablo Cody was in the middle of trying to write "a very big, commercial, four-quadrant movie" when she gave birth to her third child. After her first two kids, she had gotten back in the groove of work, but this time, shattered by exhaustion, she felt herself floundering both as a writer and as a parent.
"I was in this complete haze," Cody remembers. "It was like I was disconnected from reality. All I could do was fantasize about having somebody come and pull me out of this underwater wreckage I found myself in. I thought, I wish somebody would just show up on my porch tonight and just take over everything so that I could take care of myself."
Cody, 39, had always been dismissive of the idea of hiring a night nanny, thinking, she says, "the least I can do is wake up with my baby." But this time she decided to enlist someone to help her over the hump of sleep deprivation. The experience was revelatory.
"I was like a different mom in the morning," she says. "I was actually able to take care of my other children. I was energetic and chipper and patient."
The big studio project fell away and the idea for another, more personal story began gestating in Cody's mind -- an idea that would eventually grow into the new film Tully, in theaters Friday. "I thought, imagine if an ordinary woman who doesn't live in a world of night nannies and household help -- what if somebody stepped in and gave her that gift?" she says. "How would she transform?"
In Tully Charlize Theron stars as Marlo, an overburdened middle-aged mother of three whose life is turned upside down in unexpected ways when her wealthy brother (Mark Duplass) offers to hire a young night nanny (Mackenzie Davis) to help care for her newborn daughter. Deliberately discomfiting and shot through with dark humor, the film marks Cody's third collaboration with director Jason Reitman after the 2007 teen-pregnancy hit Juno and 2011's darkly comic Young Adult, which also starred Theron.
Even as she was writing Tully, Cody was well aware that a film that portrays a mother who is barely holding it together -- and that tackles uncomfortable questions of how class intersects with parenting -- threatened to touch a third rail in movies. "In TV, I've definitely noticed that people are more willing to embrace the flawed female protagonist, but there's still something about the mother," she says. "We can deal with an unlikable woman who's freaking out. But if she's freaking out on children, we're out."
For evidence of the risks, Cody needed to look no further than her own resume. While Juno proved a runaway hit, grossing $231 million worldwide and earning Cody an Oscar for original screenplay, Young Adult -- whose central character, an acerbic alcoholic divorcee, proved off-putting to many viewers -- failed to connect with a large audience. The 2015 dramedy Ricki and the Flash, which Cody wrote and which starred Meryl Streep as an aging rock musician, got a lukewarm reception.
"The feedback that we got from test audiences was that Ricki was a terrible person because she had chosen her music over her children," Cody says. "People do not like the image of a mother who is anything but flawless and nurturing."
Still, as raw and edgy as Cody's script seemed, when Reitman sent a copy to Theron, the actress immediately connected with it as a single mom of two young adopted children. "I had just come out of my dark tunnel," Theron says. "My little one was 6 months old and she had just moved out of sleeping in my room and was slowly starting to sleep through the night. So I was just coming out of that."
A PRIME ISSUE
In a culture that often expects women to present a soft-focus image of maternal perfection to the world, Theron knew a film delving into the emotional minefield of motherhood had the potential to strike a chord.
"We're so honest about everything -- we share what medication we take, what happens in our bedrooms -- but we don't talk necessarily about this stuff," says the actress, who gained nearly 50 pounds for the role.
"I had experienced it myself with my own kids. I definitely had moments where I felt complete judgment, and I found myself feeling a little bit ashamed for not doing it all myself or for having somebody tell me that I'm screwing my kids up by giving them formula. So (reading Cody's script) felt like a relief. I was like, 'Oh, somebody else is feeling this as well.'"
Both as the father of a young daughter and as a filmmaker drawn to flawed, messy characters, Reitman was similarly excited by the prospect of probing some of the darker corners of child-rearing. "It opened up conversations about our experiences being parents," he says. "One of the many things that no one talks about it is not knowing what to do, being scared to ask because you're supposed to know what to do and how lonely that can feel."
Cody says her primary aim in writing Tully was to take on that "myth of the supermom" by drawing from her own struggles as a parent.
"I will never be that mom who makes the Minions cupcakes for the class party -- ever," she says. "I feel like women are expected to be great at the nurturing aspect of things, and that didn't come naturally to me and that was scary. People talk about how motherhood transforms you, and it does in a sense. But in another sense I'm still the exact same impulsive, selfish knucklehead I've always been. I expected to wake up and be Mother Teresa, and that didn't happen."
Those supermom expectations can be particularly oppressive in Los Angeles, Cody says: "In L.A., you'll meet families who have insane wealth and are saying, 'You should have more kids. We have five, and it's been the greatest experience of our lives.' I'm like, 'Yeah, you love being a mom because you're rich!' I grew up with two hard-working parents who went to jobs every day that they hated and then had to come home to my disobedient ass. I don't think they romanticized family life in quite the same way as, like, yoga mom in Brentwood who can go out whenever she wants because she has an immigrant taking care of her kids."
Focus Features, which is releasing Tully, has made a particular effort to target mothers in its marketing campaign for the film. In the run-up to its release, Tully has stirred concerns from some that the film does not treat Marlo's postpartum mental-health struggles with sufficient seriousness and nuance. "Motherhood is hard, yes, but it is not this," Diana Spalding, a midwife and pediatric nurse, wrote in a piece on the website Motherly.
A READY AUDIENCE
But Cody believes that the film, which has received largely positive reviews since its debut at the Sundance Film Festival, will resonate with many mothers who rarely see the challenges of parenthood dealt with honestly onscreen. "I've had so many moms reach out to me who've only seen the trailer, saying, 'I've been waiting for this movie,'" Cody says.
In the three films he's made with Cody, all of them centered on female characters, Reitman sees a clear thematic through-line. "All the films deal with this feeling of being unsure of where you are in the arc of your lifetime," he says. "Juno is about growing up a little too fast. Young Adult is about maybe growing up a little too slow. And Tully is about that moment where you have to say goodbye to a portion of your childhood but you're not sure if you're ready for where you are in this moment."
Though some might ask whether a female director would have been a better fit for a film about the complexities of motherhood, Theron pushes back against that idea. "What makes it really beautiful is that Jason is searching for the truth of what it feels like to be a woman," she says. "We need that. We have to be careful that we don't throw a general blanket on what a female story should look like or who should make it. We should just make them and whoever wants to join on that ship should come. I welcome them."
Having dredged Tully out of her own most difficult moments as a mother, Cody is now eager to see how the film's story -- which unfolds in unexpected ways the filmmakers have been careful not to spoil -- will resonate with parents and nonparents alike.
"I want this movie to be ultimately uplifting and hopeful, and I think it does end on an optimistic note, but I also wasn't afraid to go deep with it and go to a dark place," she says. "It's the type of movie that you want people to discover and interpret. You don't want to give everything away."
MovieStyle on 05/11/2018